Skip to main content

Table 7 Summary of studies reporting on the force-time characteristics of spinal manipulation (SM) delivered to inanimate objects (e.g. human analogue manikins, instrumented tools) with no region specified (n = 6)

From: Spinal manipulation characteristics: a scoping literature review of force-time characteristics

Author/s

Year, Country

SM delivery

Profession (n)

Experience

Recipient/s (n)

Location/s

Technique/s

Interface/s

Measurement equipment

Metrological data

Inanimate objects

McCarthy et al.

2002, England45

Clin

Chiro (28)

Mixed

Tool (1)

L vertebra/tool

Superior-inferior

Clin-tool

Strain guage

No

Perle & Kawchuk

2005, Canada52

Clin

Chiro (16)

> 5y

Rigid surface (1)

NR

Pisiform/hypothenar with or without arch in hand

Clin-tool

Pressure sensor

No

Kawchuk et al.

2006, Canada42

Clin

Chiro (4)

NR

Force table/

plate (1)

Force mat

Hypothenar

Clin-tool

Load cell

No

Colloca et al.

2009, USA12

Clin

Chiro (2)

NR

Tool (1)

NR

Toggle-torque-recoil

Clin-tool

Load cell

No

DeVocht et al.

2013, USA19

Clin & Stud

Chiro (139)

Clin: NR

Stud: NR

Tool (1)

Speeder board

Toggle recoil

Clin-tool

Force transducer

No

Colloca et al.

2020, UK13

Clin & Stud

Chiro (53)

Clin: Mixed

Stud: NR (3rd /5th y)

Force table/

plate (1)

NR

Toggle-torque-recoil

Clin-tool

Load cell

No

  1. All superscript numbers in the first column refer to Appendix 2. Abbreviations: Chiro: chiropractor, Clin: clinician, L: lumbar, Mixed: experience of clinicians both > and < 5 years, (n): number of participants, NR: not reported, Stud: students, SM: spinal manipulation, y: years, >: greater than